Most readers of this column will be familiar with the unfortunate tendency of some investors to buy high and sell low. They rush into rising markets and flee when they come back to earth.
That’s a pattern we usually see in the stock market, although this year U.S. equity investors have shown patience in the face of falling markets. Where they’ve been running from is the usually staid world of bond funds.
Bond prices have been going through a downturn in 2022 like we haven’t seen in 40 years. Our latest market statistic report shows the total global bond market (hedged to Canadian dollars) was down 12.3% to the end of September, while the Canadian total bond market was down 11.8%.
Those are pretty horrible numbers for what’s supposed to be the safe bucket in your portfolio. Investors in the U.S. have responded by cashing out of bond funds in droves. Morningstar data shows that year-to-date to August 31, US$330 billion had flowed out of U.S. bond mutual funds and ETFs. Surprisingly, the opposite has occurred in Canada where bond mutual funds saw net inflows of $1.3 billion and bond ETFs saw net inflows of $4.5 billion.
The discrepancy in bond fund flows between the two countries is hard to explain; however, Canadian balanced funds—those that hold a mix of stocks and bonds—followed the U.S. pattern, experiencing a net outflow of $6.5 billion for the year.
Those investors who are fleeing bonds are focusing on the short-term pain they’ve experienced from falling fund prices but are missing out on the several reasons why bonds have actually become more attractive this year for long-term investors.
Before we look at those reasons, let’s recall why it’s been such a challenging year for bonds. Coming out of the pandemic, inflation has been surging around the world. That’s prompted central banks, including the Bank of Canada and the U.S. Federal Reserve, to raise interest rates aggressively to cool the economy and bring down inflation.
What’s more, central bankers, led by Fed Chairman Jerome Powell, have also been clear that they will do what it takes to bring price increases under control, meaning they will keep raising rates until the inflation rate comes down to around their target of 2%.
Bond prices are inversely related to interest rates so that when rates rise, bond prices fall. Therefore, rising rates have meant capital losses on bond investments. But when watching bond fund prices drop, it’s important to remember the other side of the equation – falling prices mean bonds are paying higher interest rates, or in industry parlance, they are yielding more.
In fact, rising interest rates are creating a whole new investment landscape from the one we’ve known since the financial crisis of 2008-09. The rock-bottom interest rates we’d become accustomed to are now in the rear-view mirror.
Bonds are generating more interest income than in years past and that increases expected portfolio returns – good news for long-term investors. That’s the first reason why it’s a better time to invest in bonds than it was a year ago.
The second reason is that bonds will continue to be an important diversifier for your portfolio and thus reduce its riskiness – even in periods of rising interest rates.
The stock and bond markets have been relatively well correlated this year – going down in tandem – but that’s a highly unusual occurrence. Bond prices usually have a lower correlation with stocks than most other major asset classes and are also less volatile.
Mark Haefele said in his weekly blog, published on September 26th that History suggests bonds will resume their traditional role as a diversifier. Periods when 12-month rolling total returns fall simultaneously for both stocks and bonds have been followed by periods of strong bond performance. In fact, since 1930, the 12-month bond performance following such periods has been positive 100% of the time.
No one can predict the course of interest rates, as former Bank of England governor Mervyn King has pointed out. However, the picture for bonds has brightened not worsened this year. If anything, investors who reduced their bond holdings in favour equity during the long period of low interest rates may want to revisit their asset allocation.